Sunday, September 20, 2009

Pseudo-Arguments

A pseudo-argument lacks a reasonable argument, which doesn’t allow the possibility of growth and change or the evidence to back up claims that have been made.

Each person involved in the argument are fanatically committed to their positions. Usually a rational argument requires, “reasonable participants who operate within the conventions of reasonable behavior and potentially shareable assumptions that can serve as a starting place or foundation for the argument.” (Writing Arguments) A pseudo-argument doesn’t have one or both of these conditions. It also doesn’t allow the participants of the argument to reach a common ground.

For example, I have witnessed a pseudo-argument about whether or not eating a good breakfast helps you do better on a test. There are two sides, one side continues to do well academically and they don’t have to change their opinion, and there is the other side that thinks otherwise. Because the student is doing well in school they don’t have to change their opinion, therefore common assumptions cannot be made.

Sunday, September 13, 2009

Biotech Foods

One of the most debatable topics of the twenty-first century is the biotech food debate. Biotech foods are now commonly found in stores and kitchens. Proponents of biotech foods have indicated that the products are similar to organically grown products, and the opponents say that there are dangers with the biotech industry.

This topic is debatable because of the potential health risks. The food products should be labeled so that the consumers who want to purchase biotech foods can and those who don’t want to purchase biotech foods don’t have to. By law the food and drug administration (FDA) requires all products to be labeled with nutritional content. Until such time that we are able to scientifically prove that there is no difference in the health risks. The biotech foods should be included on the nutritional content on the product.

Once again, we must not put the average consumer at risk. By labeling the biotech foods, we allow the consumer to participate in the decision process when buying biotech food products.

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Ad vs. Cartoon

The cartoon uses the genre known as visual arguments. Visual arguments can be photographs, political cartoons, drawings or anything that isn’t accompanied by text. As stated on page thirty-seven of Writing Arguments, “Visuals make strong emotional appeals, often reducing complex issues to one power perspective.” There are other forms of genres, such as the blog that I am completing now, but the genres vary depending on the audience. The ad uses evidence to support their claim, as well as a visual aspect. The genre that the ad uses would be the public affairs advocacy advertisements because its published as posters, fliers and paid advertisements which use condensed arguments to influence the audience opinion on certain issues.

In these two cases, the powerful perspective is solely aimed on the purpose of genetically engineered food. The political cartoon on page one has a hippy holding a piece of corn saying, “you don’t want this it’s genetically modified.” To me, this implied the controversy that genetically modified food has surrounded. The cartoon represented nature, and even the poor or homeless should not be deprived of nutritional foods. The ad showed that there was a hidden message, that we were all missing, and that everything that is genetically modified should be labeled and that the ad is modified to fit the average consumer.

Monday, September 7, 2009

Explicit vs. Implicit Arguments

An explicit argument states a claim and supports it by reasoning and evidence. An implicit argument doesn’t always look like an argument. These arguments are often conveyed in the forms of a photo, story, poem or cartoon. However, both types of arguments persuade the audience to a specific point of view.

The photo and the poem on page five exemplify an implicit argument because there is no ordered structure such as a thesis, reasoning or evidence. Although, the photo and poem don’t have this, they do capture vivid details and evoke powerful emotions. The words that Wilfred Own used like; vile, dim, smothering and bitter, depict an emotion of how corrupt war is and that soldiers give their life for their country.

In photography class, we would always talk about point of view, and how one photograph can capture an emotion of the viewer, and that it might change depending on the person looking at it. The photo on page five, captures emotions of the audience by urging the viewer to find the deeper meaning and make connections about the photo.

Both implicit and explicit arguments use strong persuasive power and because of this implicit arguments can be incorporated into an explicit argument.

Thursday, September 3, 2009

A Memory

We usually have to park behind my grandparents house by a nursing home because their driveway is so small the rental car doesn’t always fit, and we walk down an uncleared path of leaves and branches and go inside to a house that usually smells like vinegar and bacon. My grandparents always greet us with a hug and a kiss.

After we settled in, and everyone else was in the other room my grandfather took my hand and led me into this small room. He turned on the light and there was all this equipment that I had never seen before. He sat down and I sat on his lap, he told me that it was a ham radio, and that I was old enough to talk to people on it. He showed me the buttons and how everything worked. The microphone was huge, and he precisely called into it W3FYA and people responded. I got to sit and talk to people from far away places such as Ireland and all over the United States that had Ham radios. To this day, he lets me sit in the Ham radio room and talk to people. It was just special to do this for the first time when he presumed I was “old enough.” That same trip he told me all about his experience with the Great Depression, and World War II stories that I will want to pass on to my kids some day because that was a first hand experience that needs to be told.

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Class Reflection

AP English is what I expected it to be. The atmosphere of the class has been very comfortable and laid back. The group discussions that we have are very thought provoking and I especially enjoyed the discussions on the Great Gatsby.

There was a lot of information that I didn’t pick up when I read the book and I had interpreted the book very differently then what we discussed. So it was interesting to learn about the hidden meanings behind the book, as well as the meanings my classmates gave. This is kind of what we were talking about with the “I Could Tell You Stories,” and will talk about with, “Memory and Imagination.” Everyone remembered something for a reason that stuck out to them and it might not be the same as the person sitting next to them. The readings have all linked indirectly to each other, and with class discussions it’s easier to come away with a variety of ideas then when we started talking about the American Dream.

To be able to develop your own opinions and then manipulate them until you have developed a strong thesis statement develops the skills to make a good reader and writer.

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

Language

Language evolves, and is continuing to evolve today. Over a long period of time, the English language has evolved from Old English and has been infused from other languages. The society is growing and changing, and there are a lot of new ideas and with those ideas, our language will also change. What I mean by this is that any time there is a new invention a name is come up for it. These new words can arise accidentally, or inevitably and people just use them from there. A lot of people today use slang, and educators may worry that because of the use of slang, language is becoming more informal.

As for myself, I do feel like my language changes, especially when I‘m around different groups of people. When I’m around my friends, I find myself using more slang, but I don’t intentionally do it. Throughout the years, slang has been used much more, and being exposed to it, you start to pick it up. As I have gotten older, my vocabulary has increased and because it has increased there are much more word choices, and hopefully that will occur with everyone throughout life.

Everyday, people say new words, and they soon become popular to say. This will continue to happen and language will change, but I hope it doesn’t change too much because our language might become too informal.