Tuesday, May 18, 2010

Johnny Got His Gun

Throughout the novel, Trumbo develops many positions about war. However, at the end of the novel he really expands on beliefs on war. He believes that the establishment causes men to rise up against each other, and if this did not exist, men would not do that. I disagree with this argument because I think it is human nature that when put in a threatening situation, our “flight or fight” instinct takes over. For example, a farmer would defend his or her land if he felt threatened by the person invading, or if a burglar came into a home, the individual in the home would have to fight to protect their home. Another position Trumbo takes on war is that one shouldn’t die for ideals, but rather “concrete things” such as a mother giving up their life for their child. I disagree with this idea that there is no idea worth dying for, because there is.

Wednesday, May 5, 2010

Johnny Got His Gun

I found the way the book was written to be interesting. I have never seen an author construct a piece where the reader cannot tell if the main character is conscious or hallucinating. This is important to the storyline because Joe has suffered greatly because of the war. All he has left is a functioning brain and nothing else, so his thoughts are always sporadic and sometimes confusing to the reader. One of the best parts of the book where the reader cannot tell if Joe is hallucinating or not is when he thinks he is being eaten by the rat. Trumbo uses such great imagery that the reader can picture the scenario in their mind and start to believe that this was in fact true, yet it was only a figment of Joe’s imagination. By including the thought process of Joe during the war, he is able to show reality of war and the struggles a soldier must face.

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

The March of the Flag

In the essay, The March of the Flag, Albert Beveridge makes the claim that Americans are, “God’s chosen people.” He assumes that Americans have a superiority over everyone else, and their sole purpose is to fight for God. He also argues that, “America’s power is to save the soil for liberty and civilization.” This means that an individual does not have a choice to fight, but rather must fight. It is similar to Johnny Got His Gun because he was forced to fight in a war that he knew little about. Joe was simply fighting for the protection of America’s wonderful gifts that God has given this country. In the book Joe describes the horrors and struggle of war that he had to face in order to preserve God’s land. Moreover, he sees Americans have a moral and global obligation to spread the knowledge and superiority of America’s religion and government to all the less fortunate people.

Monday, May 3, 2010

"America the Beautiful: What We're Fighting For"

In the essay, “America the Beautiful: What We’re Fighting For,” Dinesh D’Souza discussed the conflict between the Islamic and American worlds and opinions and controversy that keeps these worlds in tension. He also talks about how lucky Americans are and how wonderful America is as a country. There are many advantages that America has over other countries. D’Souza called American society, “the greatest, freest, and most decent society in existence,” and goes as far as to say that Islamic societies produce, “wretched, servile, fatalistic and intolerant human beings.”

In the novel, Johnny Got His Gun, a young man, who like many others, goes to war because he is told by the leaders of his country to go to war. He was injured when a bomb explodes next to him, and he loses both his arms, legs, hearing, sight and can’t even speak.

The relationship between D’Souza’s essay and Johnny Got His Gun is that Johnny Got His Gun shows the reality of what war really is like. D’Souza explains the complications and problems with war, but not necessarily the consequences that come of it. Johnny Got His Gun shows how horrifying, sad and dangerous war is and the lasting impact it has on people’s lives.

Friday, April 30, 2010

Civil Disobedience

In Henry Thoreau’s essay, Resistance to Civil Government (Civil Disobedience), he explains his reasoning for refusing to pay this tax and his views on government and why it must be resisted. He looks at the importance of justice, morality and conscious of an individual. Thoreau argues that people shouldn’t let the government overrule and that it is the duty of the people to allow the government to act with injustice. Thoreau believes that was government exists in America because of tradition, and because it was practical.

The Declaration of Independence was written to request independence from Great Britain under the rule of King George III. Much like Thoreau’s essay, the settlers were trying to resist the government that was being imposed on them. The role of resistance is in place to shape and consider the will of the people. The Declaration of Independence served as the settler’s first attempt at creating a democracy, where the power would lie in the hands of the people. Resistance to democracy is important because everyone would be forced to believe the same thing. A government that has resistance allows people the freedom of thought, which is what helps to shape and enforce a democracy. It allows citizens to live freely under an established government where everything is considered “fair and balanced.”

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

"Don't Ask, Don't Tell"

An interesting topic that has come up recently in the news is the military policy of “don’t ask, don’t tell.” An independent Senator named Joseph Lieberman introduced a bill that would repeal the ban on openly gay service members in the military, but at a hearing later in the day Republican lawmakers questioned why lifting the ban was necessary. Lieberman introduced the bill in response to Obama’s pledge to end the 17-year-old “don’t ask don’t tell.” This law allows gay men and lesbians to serve in the armed services only if they keep their sexual orientation secret. At the hearing panel, there was the statistic given that from 1999 to 2008, 1.9 million people were discharged by the Department of Defense, including 8,300 because of the “don’t ask, don’t tell.” Gender is personal and I believe it should remain that way and it allows people to live their lives freely, but without fear of reprisal.

Monday, April 19, 2010

Engaging the Text #2 What is Marriage?

By starting the passage with an extended definition of marriage, Wolfson is able to make himself credible and show how much power a marriage between people can hold. He starts his definition with discussing how even though people speak many different languages, there is a word for marriage, and it always describes someone’s love and dedication to another person. This shows how marriage is a universal term, and is represented the same way no matter what culture or background someone comes from. Wolfson then describes how marriage is a personal commitment, a social statement, and a relationship with the government. He also describes the legal and economic responsibilities, and the spiritual significance marriage has for many of us. Wolfson does this to show that a marriage is a big step, and requires a lot of commitment for two people. He uses the definition to primarily represent that the union between to people should symbolize their love for one another.

I think that Wolfson’s definition is fair and sensible because it describes an accurate meaning of marriage. However, since Wolfson is a gay man it is possible that in his definition he placed a higher value to the benefits he believes marriage entails as opposed to someone else who carries the same ideas, but does have the actual benefits of marriage.

Friday, April 16, 2010

It Takes a Family

Rick Santorum uses Dr. Wade Horn’s metaphor to show how a traditional marriage where both parents live in the same household is better in comparison to a child who has grown up in a single-parent household. The families that have both a mother and a father in the same home provide for a “safe destination” whereas the families that have a single parent only “land safely” part of the time, but not as successfully as the first.

Throughout the essay Santorum uses statistics. He stated, “In one study of more than 6,000 young men ages 14 to 22, it was found that boy show grew up without a married mother and father were more than twice as likely to end up in jail as boys who did.” He is implying that families with a mother and father figure provide for a better healthier family and it is less likely for the child to get into any kind of trouble. Research has been done to show that a healthy family is one that is more likely to support one another and the kids will do well. Santorum goes on to state, “Marriage matters because children matter. Without marriage, children suffer, there is simply no better investment parents can make in their children’s future than a healthy marriage.” Therefore children who have grown up in a single-parent home have a future that may or may not be good, which is why Rick Santorum suggests that we should always choose the first plane because even though both planes offer good odds, having a mother and father in the same home provides the family with more success.

Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Appearances

Vazquez waited until the end to reveal that Brian and Mickey were both actually straight men so that it increases the effect and adds an element of surprise. Because they were perceived as gay, they were beaten up. The disclosure that the two men were actually straight helps the reader to realize that appearances are more important than many of us would like to think. The attacks of the men were all based on their appearances. The attackers only assumed that they were gay based on the way they dressed and presented themselves. People in our society will judge and hate whomever they want for whatever reason they want, the easiest of which being the way someone looks. Her disclosure adds emphasis on the dangers of biases based on appearance and how everyone is at risk even if one is not homosexual. The issue of antigay violence changes when the victims are also heterosexual because it puts more people at risk for attack. It is sad that both heterosexuals and homosexuals are at risk for choosing to be an independent individual in society, living life according to their own values and moral standards. More people would respond to a heterosexual being attacked than a homosexual. It is sad that we grow up being taught not to judge a book by its cover and to treat people with respect, but people still remain condescending based on appearances.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

Gender

I have never felt “genderized” because I have grown up in a home where my parents have encouraged me and I could do anything that I set my mind to. My parent’s roles around the house are not always typical. It is often assumed that the man of the house does the yard work and the woman does the work inside. My dad can be found doing the dishes and my mom can be found mowing the lawn. They raised me in a similar fashion. If I wanted to play soccer, I was encouraged to do so, and if I wanted to wear pants instead of a dress that was okay too. One of my favorite toys growing up was Stretch Armstrong while my Barbies sat in the corner. In terms of school, I was not like the author in the second passage where because of her height she was chosen last for things in P.E. I have always been very short, but was actually very athletic and was usually chosen first. Even today, my parents instill the values of “you can do anything,” and that doesn’t stop me from doing something a boy may do or a girl may do. I think had I grown up in a different time such as the 1950s and 1960s there would have been less opportunity for me to branch out and try the things that boys were “supposed” to do.

Friday, April 9, 2010

Transcendentalism

In many ways Eustace Conway did have some Transcendentalist qualities. Transcendentalism is the belief that nature teaches us unity and connection between all things, and that we should be engaged in processing our own world. Eustace could be considered a transcendentalist because he is someone who depends on his mind and nature, and doesn’t really need anything else. Transcendentalists also go by free thought, and understand the importance of nature and how it affects the world because you can’t trust everyone around you. One of the things that concerns Eustace is that the world revolves around material possessions and he decided to he attempts to save our nation from its own greed and sloth by living in harmony with nature. By moving away from his family and creating turtle island Eustace was able to connect with himself, escape the material world and live at peace with nature. I agree with Gilbert’s interpretation of Eustace as a transcendentalist, although I don’t believe that Eustace actively seeks to be one, his personality just included many of the beliefs of transcendentalism.

Wednesday, April 7, 2010

Nature

The lines in Emerson’s piece that really spoke to me were, “Undoubtedly we have not questions to ask which are unanswerable. We must trust the perfection of the creation so far, as to believe that whatever curiosity the order of things has awakened in our minds, the order of things can satisfy.” This statement means that nature is self-describing and has essentially no secrets. Emerson alludes to a higher being, God, who has made nature according to certain order in life. He discusses how there are some scientists who look into the order in nature, yet we have to wonder if this order exists at all. There are things in our lives that because of nature have to be followed in a certain order. Emerson believes that through nature and the belief in God, all of our questions in some way or another will be answered. However, many of us have unanswerable questions and by putting faith in God or a higher being we may achieve the answer we are looking for. Even though I already have a strong faith, I think that these lines are powerful because it questions the reader’s beliefs in why does nature exist? What am I here to do in life and is there a order that I must follow to ultimately reach a higher goal?

Tuesday, April 6, 2010

The Last American Man

Elizabeth Gilbert could have written her hero-worshipping biography of The Last American Man because she was enamored with and possibly loved Eustace Conway and that she wanted to deliver a powerful message to attempt to save our nation from its own greed and sloth by living in harmony with nature. She uses the “man of destiny,” Eustace Conway, to show the possibility that an idealistic mountain man can convert us to a mindful natural way of living. In the Last American Man, Eustace is portrayed as an extraordinary man with very ordinary flaws. Eustace lives in an idealistic world that essentially shuts others out and has no tolerance for varying levels of competence or preferences that are different than his. However, since Elizabeth Gilbert is enamored by Eustace, she often represents him as a masculine hero who can bathe in icy streams and eat road kill. On pages fifty-eight and fifty-nine Gilbert states how she feels about Eustace by describing him as a teacher and soft spoken man and compares him to many other books and so-called “mountain men.” Gilbert states, “I am the Teacher of all the People, he seemed to say as he drifted out of his world and hovered over ours. I am trusted and I am to be followed but I am not to be frenched…And he does, after all, bathe in icy streams, so the whole libido problem is a little hard to picture. Still—and this is what got me—Eustace Conway presented himself as an epic American masculine hero.”

Thursday, March 25, 2010

How the Americans Understand the Equality of the Sexes

According to the beliefs of Alexis de Tocqueville, American and European attitudes toward women are completely different. In the beginning, Tocqueville believes that Americans apply the principle of political economy and democratic equality to the sexes. Further in the reading, he states that, “They hold that ever association must have a head in order to accomplish its object, and that the natural head of the conjugal association is the man.” Tocqueville means that American women are essentially inferior to men, and they cannot do anything about their position beneath men because it was accepted this way. In the opening paragraph Tocqueville stated his thesis saying, “I believe the social changes which bring nearer to the same level the father and son, master and servant, and, in general, superiors and inferiors, will raise woman, and make her more and more the equal of man.” This was an accurate prediction of the future for women, especially because during the time that Tocqueville visited the United States, woman were much inferior to men. Women did not have the right to vote, hold property, and hold jobs outside the home. It was assumed that the women’s position in life was childrearing and educating the next generation. Over the years, woman have, as Tocqueville predicted, risen up and have gained more of a prominent position in society. As we can see today with the full equality of men and women.

Tocqueville also mentions the difference between the treatment of women in Europe compared to the United States. He believes that women in Europe are considered more equal and that they would, “give to the same functions, impose on both the same duties, and grant to both the same rights.” This means that since Europe puts a high value on equality both sexes are essentially degraded and the worse that can come of the degrading is “disorderly women and weak men.”

Friday, March 19, 2010

End of Black Boy

At the end of Black Boy, Richard Wright realizes what he wants to achieve in his life through writing, even though his hunger did not really go away. He would, “hurl words into the darkness and wait for an echo, and if an echo sounded, no matter how faintly, I would send other words to tell, to march, to fight, to create a sense of the hunger for life that gnaws in us all, to keep alive in our hearts a sense of the inexpressibly human.” Richard is saying that he can use his writing as a powerful way to express himself and his beliefs, even if the readers do not resonate with his writing. Richard uses his words to connect with the outside world because all people suffer from hunger in their lives at some point. His main goal is to challenge the world to move forward and make people think.

I agree with Wright’s realization because he found meaning in life that was once never there, and now that he has found it he can share it with the world. He is a thinker and can express his beliefs and help other people learn the same values in life. By showing people where he came from, and how he became successful he can help the reader to realize their own meaning in life.

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Poem vs Chapter 17

The reading in Black Boy and the poem by Langston Hughes are similar in that they are trying to take a stand and rise up against something they believe is unjust. They both discuss how the white world suppresses the blacks to the point where they become united. In Wright’s case even though everyone is different in the communist party, they realize that they have a common bond with one another and have the power to stand up against the higher powers that have kept them in this confined room. Wright stated that, “They would have never allowed millions of perplexed and defeated people to sit together for long hours and talk, for out of their talk was rising a new realization in life. And once this new conception of themselves had formed, no power on earth could alter it.” Wright is saying that the people in the communist party were able to put aside their differences and create one common purpose. Langston Hughes’ poem is more individualized than in the group that Wright was talking about, but he also is trying to take a stand against a group of people so that one day he may “eat at the kitchen” and not be ashamed of his skin color being different.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Artists and Politicians

I agree with Wright’s theory that artists and politicians stand at opposite poles, especially when it comes to the communist party. The politicians propagate a system and group people into categories based on certain factors such as class or importance. As Wright stated, “they oversimplify the experience of those whom they sought to lead.” Many times politicians are focused on the factors that will improve their political career and don’t necessarily make decisions based on the interests of the people and really value the importance of things. Artists, on the other hand, have the ability to create evocative and elaborate creations, but are made to appeal to a specific audience and don’t always present what is candid. However, I don’t agree with Richard that they are on completely opposite poles because both groups are trying to appeal to a specific audience, and will do what they can to sway their audiences opinion, which makes the groups somewhat similar.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Chapters 15-16

(“The essence of the irony of the plight of the Negro in America, to me, is that he is doomed to live in isolation while those who condemn him seek the basest goals of any people on the face of the earth. Perhaps it would be possible for the Negro to become reconciled to his plight if he could be made to believe that his sufferings were for some remote, high, sacrificial end; but sharing the culture that condemns him, and seeing that a lust for trash is what blinds the nation to his claims, is what sets storms to rolling in his soul.”)

In this part of the book Wright has moved from the South for the subtler North where blacks are not systematically terrorized, rather made to feel less than marginal. With the many jobs he takes and leaves, he has not been able to really have friends. He really starts to discover that what he is looking for is inside of him. These deep thoughts are in parentheses because it is something that he learns about later in his life and has a better understanding of the racial conflict that occurs. In this passage Wright realizes that the African American society is often looked down upon for having a different culture and are condemned because their differences of culture. It also mentions how the desire for material wealth blinds the society from the suffering of African Americans such as Wright. This really shows how his life situation didn’t improve a whole lot, but the he gained a better understanding of his position in society. By sharing these ideas in parentheses Wright is able to display what he has learned over the course of his life, and his opinions make the novel have a bigger effect on the reader.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Malcolm X

At the beginning of the essay Malcolm X expounds on his lack of reading skills while young, and eventually how reading became important to him today. He believes that reading shapes ones morals and principles. Without the ability to read, a basis for intellect and perception, it becomes increasingly difficult to build your own ethical views. The reading empowered Malcolm X because it gave him a sense of accomplishment in life because he was finally able to understand the world around him. Throughout his reading he discovered that minority groups are covered up and his reading allowed him to really see racism for what it is, and began to work hard to overcome the racism.

Unlike Malcolm X, Richard uses books to get away from the trials and tribulations of his life and create a fairytale world where everything is perfect. The difference is that Malcolm X reads to fit in with the world and Richard Wright does it to escape from the world. However, as Richard ages, he learns that words in books can have powerful meanings and comes to terms with the world around him instead of merely escaping.

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Action to Move

Wright’s decision to move was a positive one because it was the start of what Richard hoped was a new life, and one that did not have the oppressing views of the South. For almost all of his life Wright has dreamed of moving to the North where they will accept African Americans relatively better than the South, and allow him to pursue his love for reading and writing.

When Richard lived in Memphis he was constantly trying to make a better life for himself and not settle on anything like many of his African American peers had done. Richard realized the Chicago was not going to be free of discrimination, but was better than Memphis and where he had grown up in the Deep South. Richard doesn’t really know what to expect, but is moving with the assumption that he can make a better life for himself. He realizes that if he stays in Memphis his life won’t get any better and he would become stuck like his friend Shorty. The only downside to Wright’s moving was that he once again had to leave behind the people that he truly cared for and loved.